关于阅读的一点疑问，求诸位解答啊……

123雨季不再来UID: 3226134

这是一篇no题的第一段：Extraordinary creative activity has been characterized as revolutionary, flying in the face of what is established and producing not what is acceptable but what will become accepted. According to this formulation, highly creative activity transcends the limits of an existing form and establishes a new principle of organization. However, the idea that extraordinary creativity transcends established limits is misleading when it is applied to the arts, even though it may be valid for the sciences. Differences between highly creative art and highly creative science arise in part from a difference in their goals. For the sciences, a new theory is the goal and end result of the creative act. Innovative science produces new propositions in terms of which diverse phenomena can be related to one another in more coherent ways. Such phenomena as a brilliant diamond or a nesting bird are relegated to the role of data, serving as the means for formulating or testing a new theory. The goal of highly creative art is very different: the phenomenon itself becomes the direct product of the creative act. Shakespeare’s Hamlet is not a tract about the behavior of indecisive princes or the uses of political power; nor is Picasso’s painting Guernica primarily a propositional statement about the Spanish Civil War or the evils of fascism. What highly creative artistic activity produces is not a new generalization that transcends established limits, but rather an aesthetic particular. Aesthetic particulars produced by the highly creative artist extend or exploit, in an innovative way, the limits of an existing form, rather than transcend that form.、

这是题目：The author implies that an innovative scientific contribution is one that
(A) is cited with high frequency in the publications of other scientists
(B) is accepted immediately by the scientific community
(C) does not relegate particulars to the role of data
(D) presents the discovery of a new scientific fact
(E) introduces a new valid generalization


答案是E.

原因是艺术和科学的强对比，艺术不是generalization,所以科学是。他们是强对比没错，但是考试时怎么知道哪里和哪里对比呢……何况找科学发现没有答案，再去找艺术的，然后取反，这也太浪费时间了吧……

另外，新g没法做标记，那做文章的流程这样对不对：读文章，边读边总结，知道各段大意，看题目，找到讲这个题目的一段，然后找到这道题相关的句子，选答案。貌似不甚靠谱啊……哪有这么容易就找到对应的句子了……


求大神解答啊…………万分感谢…………

123雨季不再来UID: 3226134

求解答啊……求解答……

zhuyueruiUID: 2902370

楼主，我觉得这道题有很多可以定位的地方，可以定位到For the sciences, a new theory is the goal .
也可以定位到 Innovative science produces new propositions，当然也可以用强对比方法。
定位的时候找题目中核心词，比如这道题目核心词就是 innovative scientific，练一练就好了:)

123雨季不再来UID: 3226134

zhuyuerui 发表于 2012-7-28 18:35
楼主，我觉得这道题有很多可以定位的地方，可以定位到For the sciences, a new theory is the goal .
也可 ...

我就是定位到这两个地方才选的D啊……要想选E只能用强对比吧？那个分析是花儿写的。

zhuyueruiUID: 2902370

123雨季不再来 发表于 2012-7-29 10:25
我就是定位到这两个地方才选的D啊……要想选E只能用强对比吧？那个分析是花儿写的。

lz，propositions就是generalization的意思啊