阅读一题

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

Many critics of Emily Bronte’s novel WutheringHeights see its second part as a counterpoint (a complementing or contrasting item: OPPOSITE) that comments on, if it does not reverse, the first part, where a “romantic” reading receives more confirmation. Seeing the two parts as a whole is encouraged by the novel’s sophisticated structure, revealed in its complex use of narrators and time shifts. Granted that the presence of these elements need not argue an authorial awareness of novelistic construction comparable to that of Henry James, their presence does encourage attempts to unify the novel’s heterogeneous parts. However, any interpretation that seeks to unify all of the novel’s diverse elements is bound to be somewhat unconvincing. This is not because such an interpretation necessarily stiffens into a thesis (although rigidity in any interpretation of this or of any novel is always a danger), but because Wuthering Heights has recalcitrant elements of undeniable power that, ultimately, resist inclusion in an all-encompassing interpretation. In this respect, Wuthering Heights shares a feature of Hamlet.4 i' ?! g& X) ?3 w$ `  X' u$ ]


19.
The author of the passage would be most likely to agree that an interpretation of a novel should. l2 M$ r: }2 P
(A) not try to unite heterogeneous elements in the novel
(B) not be inflexible in its treatment of the elements in the novel
(C) not argue that the complex use of narrators or of time shifts indicates a sophisticated structure  U4 Y9 b  N5 E5 r6 p4 T
(D) concentrate on those recalcitrant elements of the novel that are outside the novel’s main structure（B）# {0 Y' R: h, [9 I% U
(E) primarily consider those elements of novelistic construction of which the author of the novel was aware3

为什么不能选A？答案是B

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

求助

EnolateUID: 3283311

Many critics of Emily Bronte’s novel WutheringHeights see its second part as a counterpoint (a complementing or contrasting item: OPPOSITE) that comments on, if it does not reverse, the first part, where a “romantic” reading receives more confirmation. Seeing the two parts as a whole is encouraged by the novel’s sophisticated structure, revealed in its complex use of narrators and time shifts. Granted that the presence of these elements need not argue an authorial awareness of novelistic construction comparable to that of Henry James, their presence does encourage attempts to unify the novel’s heterogeneous parts. However, any interpretation that seeks to unify all of the novel’s diverse elements is bound to be somewhat unconvincing. This is not because such an interpretation necessarily stiffens into a thesis (although rigidity in any interpretation of this or of any novel is always a danger), but because Wuthering Heights has recalcitrant elements of undeniable power that, ultimately, resist inclusion in an all-encompassing interpretation. In this respect, Wuthering Heights shares a feature of Hamlet.

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

Enolate 发表于 2012-11-1 18:34
Many critics of Emily Bronte’s novel WutheringHeights see its second part as a counterpoint (a comp ...

Granted that the presence of these elements need not argue an authorial awareness of novelistic construction comparable to that of Henry James, their presence does encourage attempts to unify the novel’s heterogeneous parts.

这句话要怎么理解，感觉很难懂意思。。。

EnolateUID: 3283311

钰剑乘风 发表于 2012-11-1 21:57
Granted that the presence of these elements need not argue an authorial awareness of novelistic co ...

我做这篇的时候这句也看了好多遍。。
考虑到这些元素的出现并不是为了说明作者意识了到这种结构能与H J的小说结构相媲美，那么它们的出现就确实是鼓励人们尝试将小说的不同部分统一在一起

= =我自己都觉得别扭

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

Enolate 发表于 2012-11-1 22:33
我做这篇的时候这句也看了好多遍。。
考虑到这些元素的出现并不是为了说明作者意识了到这种结构能与H J的 ...

已经很清楚了，多谢哦

holydoraUID: 3348883

although rigidity in any interpretation of this or of any novel is always a danger   这句话是解题关键句，明白表示什么是danger

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

holydora 发表于 2012-11-2 08:53
although rigidity in any interpretation of this or of any novel is always a danger   这句话是解题关键 ...

:)明白了。谢谢

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

Enolate 发表于 2012-11-1 18:34
Many critics of Emily Bronte’s novel WutheringHeights see its second part as a counterpoint (a comp ...

有空帮我看看其他的阅读问题行么？:)

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

holydora 发表于 2012-11-2 08:53
although rigidity in any interpretation of this or of any novel is always a danger   这句话是解题关键 ...

有空帮我看看其他的阅读问题行么？:)我还有一些问题没有回答呢？

holydoraUID: 3348883

钰剑乘风 发表于 2012-11-2 10:20
有空帮我看看其他的阅读问题行么？我还有一些问题没有回答呢？

坛子上有个尚友的阅读解析，还有个全真题详解，在置顶的帖子里有，你可以下下来看，你找的到那个帖子吧？我找找给你

holydoraUID: 3348883

https://bbs.gter.net/thread-1296750-1-1.html
这个里面，阅读那里，尚友 和 全真解析
当然，要是还有问题，咱一起讨论，呵呵

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

holydora 发表于 2012-11-2 10:27
https://bbs.gter.net/thread-1296750-1-1.html
这个里面，阅读那里，尚友 和 全真解析
当然，要是还 ...

恩恩，我去看看，谢谢啦~~

EnolateUID: 3283311

钰剑乘风 发表于 2012-11-2 10:20
有空帮我看看其他的阅读问题行么？我还有一些问题没有回答呢？

有空我帮你看看  但是我总是在干活，就忙里偷闲的时候上上网。。
那些NO.题我都没有做，期待其他同学和你讨论吧~ 楼上同学提供的也很有帮助啊~

钰剑乘风UID: 3279007

Enolate 发表于 2012-11-2 11:48
有空我帮你看看  但是我总是在干活，就忙里偷闲的时候上上网。。
那些NO.题我都没有做，期待其他同学和你 ...

恩恩，谢谢~~