[阅读]求问36套exercise11的第九题==

sanguine1211UID: 3367686

Ragtime is a musical form that synthesizes folk
   melodies and musical techniques into a brief quadrille-
   like structure, designed to be played—exactly as written
   Line —on the piano. A strong analogy exists between  
5  European composers like Ralph Vaughan Williams,   
   Edward Grieg, and Anton Dvorak who combined folk
   tunes and their own original materials in larger
   compositions and the pioneer ragtime composers in the
   United States. Composers like Scott Joplin and James  
10  Scott were in a sense collectors or musicologists,
   collecting dance and folk music in Black communities
   and consciously shaping it into brief suites or
   anthologies called piano rags.

9. Which of the following is most nearly analogous in   
   source and artistic character to a ragtime composition  
as described in the passage?   

(A) Symphonic music derived from complex jazz  
       motifs
  (B) An experimental novel based on well-known  
       cartoon characters
  (C) A dramatic production in which actors invent  
       scenes and improvise lines
  (D) A ballet whose disciplined choreography is  
    based on folk-dance steps   
  (E) A painting whose abstract shapes evoke  
        familiar objects in a natural landscape

答案选D，这篇的重点不是讲ragtime是由两种形式结合而成的么，那么类比就也要体现两种形式，D只是based on folk-dance steps啊，我选的C，actor invent scenes and improvise lines刚好是两方面啊

我这样想有什么错么？

烨焰UID: 3247176

题目说in source，对应文章中的pioneer。
这些pioneer composers were collectors。
先collecting再shaping，又和文章第一句相呼应，说明R是在原有基础上进行加工产生的。
而C选项两个都是原创，D选项有原材料。
————————
个人拙见。。。

yvesxhUID: 3305014

D项和文中都是讲高雅正统和通俗流行的结合

spring9218UID: 3150989

exactly as written Line 和 disciplined choreography 对应，回应题干中的 artistic character