- 最后登录
- 2020-11-12
- 在线时间
- 98 小时
- 寄托币
- 14757
- 声望
- 0
- 注册时间
- 2005-5-3
- 阅读权限
- 50
- 帖子
- 242
- 精华
- 5
- 积分
- 15512
- UID
- 208370
![Rank: 9](template/archy_plt8/image/star_level3.gif) ![Rank: 9](template/archy_plt8/image/star_level3.gif) ![Rank: 9](template/archy_plt8/image/star_level1.gif)
- 声望
- 0
- 寄托币
- 14757
- 注册时间
- 2005-5-3
- 精华
- 5
- 帖子
- 242
|
12月29号 分析范文 汗
Issue test8
"Wisdom is rightfully attributed not to people who know what to look for in life but to people who know what to overlook."
SAMPLE-5 (score 5)
Never before in history have people been so beset with the overflow of ideas and images that the modern human must endure. We are constantly [bombarded with ]news, advertising, and entertainment, so much so that we are often at a loss as to where we should focus our attention. This has lead to what many media critics have called "information anxiety," a term used to describe the paralysis the ordinary human experiences when attempting to organize and synthesize the vast amounts of data that move past her everyday. Now, more than ever before, it can be seen that wisdom truly is attributable to those "who know what to overlook."[引出观点,很明确]
[评论:Beginning with a strong description of the current state of information overload, the first paragraph provides a context for the issue and takes a clear position agreeing with the stated claim.]
The Internet is a good example of the effects of information overload on people. Many people receive hundreds of email messages a day, yet there is no possible way for them to respond, let alone read, all of these messages. Through practice they learn to pick out what will be of interest and to ignore the rest. A similar phenomena occurs when a person is "browsing the web." Information, both trivial and profound, float by in a disorganized way.[这个句子好] A person learns to ignore what is not relevant to their search. This is easily demonstrated by watching a person new to the Internet next to someone who is a veteran of the net. The new person will stumble on loads of irrelevant information while the veteran will most likely proceed to the information she seeks. This ability to overlook useless information is not only applicable to the net; consider the older but more established form of information known as the book.[很常见的例子,阐述的真是细致]
Ever since Guttenberg rolled out his first few pages from his press humans have been wondering how to synthesize all this knowledge. Each year more and more books are written and published, more and more information is available to the public through bookstores and libraries, and each year the average person must struggle harder to find what she needs to know.. This is one of the primary reasons people are sent to college: they are taught how to access and research information they need.
It is only through experience that one understands how to overlook useless data. This is most likely what the author of the above quote meant.[感觉这篇文章开始的时候展开的挺好的,怎么虎头蛇尾呢,语言还是用词不错的,但是觉得相比6分的,思想等方面就差多了]
COMMENTARY
This response presents [a well-developed analysis] of the issue.
Beginning with a strong description of the current state of information overload, the first paragraph provides a context for the issue and takes a clear position agreeing with the stated claim. The Internet example is well chosen and well developed, clearly supporting the point that wisdom involves learning to ignore what is not relevant. The reference to books reinforces this position but does little to advance the argument or add insightful analysis. The conclusion restates an earlier point, adding little to the analysis.
Despite a few instances of imprecise reference (e.g., "this has" and "all this knowledge"), the argument is presented clearly and coherently, meriting a score of 5. To earn a higher score, the response would need to develop a more thoughtful analysis of the issue.
SAMPLE-6 (score 6)
The quotation is certainly correct, insofar as it describes at least an element of wisdom. In other words, I do agree with the proposition, subject to the proviso that the achievement of wisdom may well also involve other traits or attributes.[提出了自己的观点,很简练,很独特]
[关于开头,评论:The response opens with a clear endorsement of the stated claim, along with an acknowledgement that wisdom involves additional traits.]
Having qualified my answer somewhat, I must[ endorse ]the principles put forth in the quotation. [ Overlooking -- or, perhaps, forgetting -- is a crucial skill one needs to master in order to navigate the often-treacherous paths of life without undue torment.这个解释专业的] From my own experience, and from observations of friends, family members and business associates,[显得很有说服力] I am well aware of the[ pitfalls] which [await] those who fail to overlook the petty, the unnecessary and the irrelevant.[这段的用词很精确,承上启下]
In modern America, as it happens, the importance of overlooking is probably greater than ever before. Even a person trying to lead a quiet, simple life encounters [an endless stream of annoyances形象, errors and petty demands] such as paperwork, filing numbers and taxes; long lines at the bank; [exponentially aggravating] traffic jams and sullen, uncooperative coworkers and neighbors. [展开的真细,用的形容词也真好] Those of us who cannot overlook such annoyances will invariably[ succumb to ]self-defeating dismay.[结构层次很好,中心句,展开,总结]
The ability to overlook also reflects a healthy sense of [proportion and priorities].[每个段落的中心句都很简明] The wise "overlooker" will ignore his or her spouse's failings after making a [considered] judgment that these are [outweighed, in the long run, by greater and more significant strengths.佩服形容词用的这么精确] for example, what wise or reasonable person would destroy a marriage solely because an otherwise faithful, kind, generous, intelligent and prosperous partner occasionally tosses socks on the floor?[问句的好作用哦]
An elderly aunt of mine makes a striking example.[引出例子,还是自己身边的例子] Long widowed, she now spends her days sitting in her apartment, carping endlessly about the many relatives who have slighted her. Nobody calls enough. Nobody pays her any attention. Nobody cares, she says.[长短句结合,真是有变化]
And, indeed, why should they? [问句,又用到了哦] Who wants to visit with someone, elderly or otherwise, who does nothing but complain, find fault and scour for slights? Were she wiser, perhaps she would ignore or even suppress her [interminable grievances ]and take more interest in the world [at large], including the very individuals whose attention she purportedly craves.[对上面的例子进行阐述,词语上的精确使用,句子的多样化让内容显得丰富,又不重复]
The paradigm of overlooking applies with equal force in the worlds of business and politics. [从生活转到更深层次] Look at Richard Nixon: [ a brilliant, often original thinker,] he was nonetheless continually obsessed with minutiae and the unimportant. On some level, I'm sure, he himself realized the dramatic impact of such a glaring character flaw; when the situation was long past salvaging, he [exhorted ]his staff and friends to "Never be petty," a dictum he honored far more in the breach than in the observance.[这个例子用的有特色,从语言句子上都不落俗套,并且是紧紧围绕中心,真正做到了例子为论证服务]
More prosaically, in business and everyday life, it is indeed the wise person who overlooks or ignores a vast amount. Why come home every day nurturing a grudge?[问句哦] Why spend time grappling with activities, people or attitudes which bring nothing but pain and torment? Still, most of us do, at least somewhat, and find ourselves far diminished for it.
In sum, I think it's safe to say that much in this world merits not even a cursory examination, and those among us are wiser and happier who can successfully budget their time and energy in order to avoid negativity.[结尾就一个长句,却归纳了总有的中心,很简练]
COMMENTARY
[This is a thoughtful, well-articulated analysis of the issue.]
The response opens with a clear endorsement of the stated claim, along with an acknowledgement that wisdom involves additional traits. The writer then begins building an argument that modern life is so full of "petty annoyances" that it would be "self-defeating" to pay much attention to them. Using, first, examples that illustrate the trivial demands encountered everyday (e.g., paperwork, traffic jams), the analysis moves on to personal types of experiences (a partner’s annoying habits; an aunt’s self-pity) and then to politics, where, the writer implies, Nixon met his political demise at least partly because of his obsession with "minutiae and the unimportant." [The examples clearly support the writer’s position and lead effectively to the concluding observation about learning to "budget" our time and energy to avoid the negative aspects of life.这里关于举例的作用,很好]
[In several places, the skillful use of questions helps move the analysis along. 提问的作用,有时候在层次没办法做的那些清晰时,可以用这个办法] And throughout, [the skillful use of sentence variety and precise vocabulary combine to convey meaning effectively关于句子的多样化和词语的精确多强调都不为过,只是难做到], as in this excerpt: "when the situation was long past salvaging, he [Nixon] exhorted his staff and friends to ‘Never be petty,’ a dictum he honored far more in the breach than in the observance." This kind of insightful, articulate analysis merits a score of 6. |
|