【0706G-CRUSADE小组】第三次作业总结贴 i41 a51

CRUSADE小组UID: 2304114

请同志们在下面跟贴讨论。

=====================Issue====================
【题目】

Issue41

Such nonmainstream areas of inquiry as astrology, fortune-telling, and psychic and paranormal pursuits play a vital role in society by satisfying human needs that are not addressed by mainstream science.

【参考链接】
0506G同主题写作第十一期---------------Issue41

  ====================Argument===================
【题目】

Argument51

“Doctors have long suspected that secondary infections may keep some patients from healing quickly after severe muscle strain. This hypothesis has now been proved by preliminary results of a study of two groups of patients. The first group of patients, all being treated for muscle injuries by Dr. Newland, a doctor who specializes in sports medicine, took antibiotics regularly throughout their treatment. Their recuperation time was, on average, 40 percent quicker than typically expected. Patients in the second group, all being treated by Dr. Alton, a general physician, were given sugar pills, although the patients believed they were taking antibiotics. Their average recuperation time was not significantly reduced. Therefore, all patients who are diagnosed with muscle strain would be well advised to take antibiotics as part of their treatment.”

【参考链接】
0606G同主题写作第十期--------------Argument51

vanluckerUID: 2267009

issue41好难啊
以前都没怎么琢磨过什么占星术和手相学
我那篇有个论点是非主流阻碍人类接受科学,影响社会发展,我举了个布鲁诺被烧死的例子,说是因为那时侯人们迷信占星术...后面补充下是教会干的....感觉太牵强了, 本来想举伽利略, 想想也和布鲁诺差不多,感觉应该是用在科学与宗教关系上....其他例子又想不出来,郁闷,谁帮我想想啊??Thanx a million.

xixiaikoUID: 2302263

我觉得《达芬奇密码》里面有一些素材可以用呢，呵呵~

个人觉得，看重“非主流”的概念，而忽略了其后进一步对这个概念的范围限制“inquiry as astrology, fortune-telling, and psychic and paranormal”，会容易让人把“非主流”和“主流”对立起来，然后从对比的角度来论证。而实际上，当谈到astrology, fortune-telling, and psychic and paranormal 限定下的inquiry时，我觉得是指对这个世界运作方式的解释。古时的解释方式是原始宗教，现在是科学和哲学，而现在科学解释不了的就是现代宗教（广义的哲学）。用历史发展的眼光分析会更灵活一点。

写完Issue背后一片冷汗，上厕所都有点打战了。。。。。。

[ 本帖最后由 xixiaiko 于 2007-2-25 02:17 编辑 ]

vanluckerUID: 2267009

.....我觉得这篇应该是在非主流,人类需求,社会作用三者间起来论述
同时我觉得题目中举的什么astrology等等只是例子,而不是限定的意思
大家觉得如何?

aggie_agathaUID: 2198539

恩 题目用了such as，那么主要功能还是举例，不是限定。

ps：看鬼谷子的分析，astrology fortunetelling 和paranomal pursuits是两个层面的。不知各位怎么处理？

aggie_agathaUID: 2198539

存点资料
占星术 《科学与怪异》http://www.oursci.org/lib/paranormal/05.htm

中文的，我习惯先看点中文对关键词有了把握再看英文。