逻辑10套ex6-9

hjn1225UID: 2630509

In a recent film set in seventeenth-century Europe, the
hero is seen doing the crawl, a swimming stroke not
known in Europe before the 1920's.However, since
moviegoers obviously are not experts in the history of
swimming strokes, for most of the film's audiences this
blunder clearly cannot have interfered with whatever
sense of historical authenticity the film otherwise
achieved.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument given?
(A) The film was widely praised for being historically
plausible, even though it portrayed many events
that were not historically attested.
(B) The scene that shows the film's hero doing the
crawl is a rescue scene pivotal to the film's action,
and parts of it are even shown a second time, in a
flashback.
(C) Makers of historical films, even of those set as
recently as the nineteenth century, routinely strike
compromises between historical authenticity and
the need to keep their material accessible to a
modern audience, as in the actors' speech patterns.
(D) The crawl that European swimmers used in the
1920's was much less efficient and more
awkward-looking than the crawl that is currently
taught.
(E) A slightly earlier film featuring an eighteenth
century sea battle in Europe was ridiculed in
numerous popular reviews for the historical lapse
of showing a sailor doing the crawl in swimming
to safety.


答案选E.
虽然我做对了,但反复读之后还是没懂这题究竟在说什么..

okqishiUID: 3245371

题目的意思是：“最近一部背景为17世纪欧洲的电影，片中男主角用了自由泳的泳姿，这种泳姿在1920年之前是不被大家所知道的。然而，由于喜欢看电影的人显然不是关于泳姿历史方面的专家，故对于大部分观众来说，关于这个泳姿方面的失误，不会妨碍该电影在展示其历史真实性其他方面的成功。”

再来看选项：
A.扯蛋
B.扯蛋
C.扯蛋
D.扯蛋
E.nice！就你了
over

okqishiUID: 3245371

补充：关于otherwise韦氏的解释:

otherwise  adv.
Function:           adverb
Date:               13th century

1 : in a different way or manner
2 : in different circumstances  
3 : in other respects  
4 : if not  
5 : NOT ― paired with an adjective, adverb, noun, or verb to indicate its contrary or to suggest an indefinite alternative   

标红的那个解释经常被我们忽略...

846136085UID: 2987171

1# hjn1225
原题说，观众不会那么在乎一些细节
E说，另一部电影因为细节的错误被取消了，这不就是weaken嘛
所以E咯

hjn1225UID: 2630509

3# okqishi
thx.我没看懂的主要原因之一就是不懂otherwise..