祝福我的爱猪小胖

scarlett2007UID：2307255

1. 12楼的话似乎是有点过了。很多其他学校的学生都有机会去top 10，只是数量少一些，而且平时不怎么爱上bbs报而已.
推荐信也不一定得是华人的。

2. 但LZ这个帖子似乎也没啥意义，没提供啥信息，对大家没啥帮助。前一段也经常有这样的帖子。建议去寄托心情之类的版面。

crazygyzUID：2251573

原帖由 wzhias 于 2007-3-22 21:43 发表


这种背景，top10 almost impossible. 你怎么知道给你写的教授就牛。牛RL都在PKU.做个好梦吧:o

可悲,可叹,原来你的认识也就这么点水平.

tip: Hong Kong has been merged to China for 10 years

crazygyzUID：2251573

原帖由 wzhias 于 2007-3-22 23:34 发表


华人最牛的RL 无非出自以下几个学校：PKU(ccer, GSM), WHU(IAS), Tsinghua U, XMU(WYN), Fudan U, ZSU, SHUFE

给你一个到现在为止的不完全offer列表：

Harvard (Kennedy):  may be CUHK (ZSU)
UC Be ...

这么武断的argument只能用武断的debate来回应了: 说句老实话,您老提的那些学校的faculty我都看过,还真没觉得他们"牛"在哪里,更从何称的上华人最牛,真是笑谈.

不说多了,你觉得"华人最牛"的数学faculty在PKU? 很负责任的告诉你,您又无知了.

请不要拿无知当资本炫耀,谢谢

crazygyzUID：2251573

原帖由 zbin915 于 2007-3-1 01:19 发表
小胖很牛，有很牛的RP,很牛的研究背景+英文水平，很牛教授写的牛RL，于是申请了很牛的学校……
三月到了，我祝福我最最亲爱的举世无双的牛GG能拿到牛Offer，在我心中你永远是最牛的:loveliness:
三月是offfe ...

Best luck for u! Since to enroll in the top 10 programs need not only ur competitive background. Luck matters a lot too.

Many of my friends got rejected by univ. like Cornell, Berkerly or UPENN but got fellowships from UChicago, Stanford, Princeton or MIT.

btw, as long as I know, most of the fellowships of top10 programs have already been sent out.

wzhiasUID：2136670

这位大哥／大姐，首先您看清楚，这里是finance/economcs NOT Math.你提PKU的数学系是什么意思。

不过我承认，对PKU不爽是很正常的，毕竟它占了太多的资源，但他的faculty确实强，这个是事实。

您觉得，如果您想得到最牛的华人的rl,除了我列的几个学校外，其他的可能性大吗，当然我承认别的学校也有可能？

请不要跟我提下面几个长年在国外不回国长期教课的华人大牛，Prof Zhou Lin@ASU， Prof Xiong Wei @ Princeton, Prof Fang Hanming @Yale, Prof Shi Shouyong@UTronto, Prof Huang Ming@Stanford, Prof Fan Jianqing@ Stanford, Prof Chen Xiaohong@NYU, Prof Bai Jushan@NYU这些不算我说的能在大陆写rl的华人大牛。

内地一般学校prof写的rl有用吗？？大多学生自己写rl，老师签字，美国人早烦这套了，无聊的陶瓷，能在top100拿到好offer都很难，更别提top 10。

从您老的话看，您的实力已经很强了，对PKU的老师如此不屑，敢问您 AER, JET, GEB,JEDC, JMathE, JME, JDeveE, RandJ, RES是不是都扫过了，如果您都扫过了，因此而不屑PKU的老师，我绝对服，真心认错。

那请牛人留个名吧。

请不要拿无知当资本炫耀,谢谢

这句话说的很好，但是我们两谁无知呢？请不要再有类似的攻击，我们可以用事实来证明自己的观点，但不要打嘴仗。OK！！！！！！！！！！！！

原帖由 crazygyz 于 2007-3-23 01:22 发表


这么武断的argument只能用武断的debate来回应了: 说句老实话,您老提的那些学校的faculty我都看过,还真没觉得他们"牛"在哪里,更从何称的上华人最牛,真是笑谈.

不说多了,你觉得"华人最牛& ...

[ 本帖最后由 wzhias 于 2007-3-23 03:03 编辑 ]

wzhiasUID：2136670

原帖由 zbin915 于 2007-3-23 00:03 发表
楼上原来是WHU的托

呵呵，敢问我托起了什么呀？你对这些学校的申请情况了解吗？
我只是说一下我知道的情况，我没有夸大，我提供的信息都是真实的。 WHU好像今年申请的不好。

另外，我绝对没有意思在这里打嘴仗，仅仅说出我知道的事实而已。

nbjimmyUID：2312520

这个帖我们应该祝福他们的吧 而不是在这里拌什么嘴 对吧

pku的确是很好 我们不否认 其他学校也不差 对吧
我不清楚今年cuhk拿到harvard的是哪位 如果没猜错的话 是欧先生了 今天还在一块 恭喜一下了

也祝楼主及家人有好的offer

wzhiasUID：2136670

Dear, guy crazygyz ,

If I am correct, I am sure you are in HKU. You estimation may be based on your faculty's publication, but you need not compare them with the faculty in mainland. Some mainland students apply to HK's Universiteis first and then transfer to the US' U by the strong recommendations from the professors in HK's Universityes. So these students will get much better offers than the mainland's applicants.   

CW-Yuan can send students to UChicago but not others, because he has strong relationship with UChicago, but UPenn , UC Berkeley will not care him. The PKU professors also have strong relationship with other top U, such as Yale, UPenn, Harvard; Tsinghua has very strong realtionship with UCBerkeley. The XMU has strong relation with Cornell, as I know, one student from XMU has got fellowship from Cornell, and Cornell always admits only one mainland applicant each year. So, you can see, in mainland you will have more chance to go to the top US' U, if you are in the U I listed above. Also, you know, most top U can only admit 1 or 2 Chinese applicants. In this case, do you think it's possible for the students outside these Universities to be admitted by the top U only with the average RL?

原帖由 crazygyz 于 2007-3-23 01:27 发表


Best luck for u! Since to enroll in the top 10 programs need not only ur competitive background. Luck matters a lot too.

Many of my friends got rejected by univ. like Cornell, Berkerly or ...

[ 本帖最后由 wzhias 于 2007-3-23 03:47 编辑 ]

nbjimmyUID：2312520

呵呵 我们不要在这里讨论这个问题好么 如果你有兴趣讨论的话 可以另外开个帖子么 这里是给别人祝福的

p.s.我不知道hku情况 感觉这几年e和f的情况都不是很好

scarlett2007UID：2307255

Which offer(s) do WHU get this year?

weiweizhuUID：179352

华中科技大和武大的关系也很多了

发现华工现在经济申请得很好

weiweizhuUID：179352

还有回18楼的
现在貌似zju的数学最牛了，丘成桐现在在那里

今年zju的数学拿了两个harvard的全奖，还全都是本科生

nbjimmyUID：2312520

我不客气点说吧 是cuhk

crazygyzUID：2251573

lol, this becomes more & more interesting.

You're right I'm in HKU. However I'm not saying that the economics faculty of HKU is the best among all. In fact, HKUST, CUHK also have extremely strong faculty, if not stronger than HKU , or saying, PKU. Also CUHK has the best math faculty in the greater China or even Asia-Pacific.

What's more, the students who got admitted to top5 US programs hardly depend on the so called "relations". Prof.Wing Suen, Prof. Richard Wong, Dr.C.W. Yuen or even other several professors with UChicago Ph.D have very strong relations with their alma mater. But as far as I know, the students who have their recommendations all go to univ. other than UChicago, and the student who got admitted by UChicago hasn't had RLs from any of them. Tricky isn't it? Relations can help, but others matter too.

I admit that most of the top offers in mainland China have gone to the univ. you have mentioned. But if you have learned some empirical economic analysis theories, you'll know that your conclusion is biased. But whether it is determined, or most explained by your saying is questionable. I'm not going to debate with u here but I can say with responsibility that if you check the Ph.D candidates within the top US univ. you should find that the place where u graduate doesn't mean everything.

Furthermore, if u're using the word "Chinese" Hua Ren (pardon me since this lab doesn't have sim Chinese input software >_<), you should be careful because you have included more than you think.

Anyway, I'm interested in this topic so if you want further discussion, send it to jakegao1024@gmail.com if I had the honor.

P.S. the journals you mentioned are some of my regular reading, albeit I cannot understand them all, or say, a great many of them. lol

crazygyzUID：2251573

if I have to rank the ECON faculties mentioned above, I would rank them as:

1. HKUST
2. CUHK, HKU
3. PKU, (NTU)

sorry again since I'm not so fimiliar with universities in Taiwan.