一题吴中东阅读 A85-1 英国雪莱《科学怪人》和布朗蒂《呼啸山庄》之比较

Lucy_2014UID: 3520489

    在网上没有找到合适的解答，吴中东上面也没有对错误选项做解释。

Notable as important nineteenth-century novels by women, Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein
and Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights treat women very differently. Shelley produced a
“masculine” text in which the fates of subordinate female characters seem entirely dependent
on the actions of male heroes or anti-heroes. Bronte produced a more realistic narrative,
portraying a world where men battle for the favors of apparently high-spirited, independent
women. Nevertheless, these two novels are alike in several crucial ways. Many readers are
convinced that the compelling mysteries of each plot conceal elaborate structures of allusion
and fierce, though shadowy, moral ambitions that seem to indicate metaphysical intentions,
though efforts by critics to articulate these intentions have generated much controversy. Both
novelists use a storytelling method that emphasizes ironic disjunctions between different
perspectives on the same events as well as ironic tensions that inhere in the relationship
between surface drama and concealed authorial intention, a method I call an evidentiary
narrative technique.

17.  The primary purpose of the passage is to
(A) defend a controversial interpretation of two novels
(B) explain the source of widely recognized responses to two novels
(C) delineate broad differences between two novels
(D) compare and contrast two novels
(E) criticize and evaluate two novels

做了两遍，都错选D,答案是E
文章自认为是读懂了，前面讲他们的不同，后面说他们的相同，选D 为什么不可以？是不是要把compare和contrast的位置颠倒一下才对？还请指点为什么D不可以选呢？

韦伯斯特的解释
compare
: to say that (something) is similar to something else
: to look at (two or more things) closely in order to see what is similar or different about them or in order to decide which one is better
: to be as good or as bad as something else : to be on the same level or in the same category as something else

contrast
1.
: to be different especially in a way that is very obvious
: to compare (two people or things) to show how they are different
2.
： something that is different from another thing
: a difference between people or things that are being compared
: the act of comparing people or things to show the differences between them


谢谢解答！

crazyrobinUID: 2368627

答案错了
D

天薇凉UID: 3403940

吴中东答案有的有问题，用资料大全对答案吧

Lucy_2014UID: 3520489

crazyrobin 发表于 2014-5-23 20:45
答案错了
D

谢谢！

Lucy_2014UID: 3520489

天薇凉 发表于 2014-5-23 20:51
吴中东答案有的有问题，用资料大全对答案吧

谢谢！是发现有些吴中东上有些答案和另一个版本的答案对不上~

Lucy_2014UID: 3520489

陈晓曼 发表于 2014-5-23 23:02
真的K博娱乐城假的？ 对不对啊

是少部分对不上