求助一篇短文章

无敌浩克OneUID: 3605802

The author of the passage concedes which of the following about the Vinaver theory?
Initially the Vinaver theory that Malory’s eight romances, once thought to be fundamentally unified, were in fact eight independent works produced both a sense of relief and an unpleasant shock. Vinaver’s theory comfortably explained away the apparent contradictions of chronology and made each romance independently satisfying. It was, however, disagreeable to find that what had been thought of as one book was now eight books. Part of this response was the natural reaction to the disturbance of set ideas. Nevertheless, even now, after lengthy consideration of the theory’s refined but legitimate observations, one cannot avoid the conclusion that the eight romances are only one work. It is not quite a matter of disagreeing with the theory of independence, but of rejecting its implications: that the romances may be taken in any or no particular order, that they have no cumulative effect, and that they are as separate as the works of a modern novelist.
1.        The author of the passage concedes which of the following about the Vinaver theory?
(A) It gives a clearer understanding of the unity of Malory’s romances.
Not the understanding of the unity, but seperation
(B) It demonstrates the irrationality of considering Malory’s romances to be unified.
(C) It establishes acceptable links between Malory’s romances and modern novels.
(D) It unifies earlier and later theories concerning the chronology of Malory’s romances.
(E) It makes valid and subtle comments about Malory’s romances.

这道题答案选E，给出的理由是倒数第二句， after lengthy consideration of the theory’s refined but legitimate observations, one cannot avoid the conclusion that the eight romances are only one work.
但是这是读者根据V的理论得出的结论呀？V自己得出的结论是八本书独立。题目问的究竟是作者得出的理论还是V本身的理论呀？

无敌浩克OneUID: 3605802

还有这篇
Tillie Olsen’s fiction and essays have been widely and rightly acknowledged as major contributions to American literature. Her work has been particularly valued by contemporary feminists. Yet few of Olsen’s readers realize the extent to which her vision and choice of subject are rooted in an earlier literary heritage—the tradition of radical political thought, mostly socialist and anarchist, of the 1910’s and 1920’s, and the Old Left tradition of the 1930’s. I do not mean that one can adequately explain the eloquence of her work in terms of its political origins, or that left-wing politics were the single most important influence on it. My point is that its central consciousness—its profound understanding of class and gender as shaping influences on people’s lives—owes much to that earlier literary heritage, a heritage that, in general, has not been sufficiently valued by most contemporary literary critics.
标红的句子难道不是说的political though 和 Old left tradition两个东西吗？这两个东西都是political tradition?哪里看出来的

无敌浩克OneUID: 3605802

顶起继续求助，之前收到了回复提醒，可是没有帖子，这是神马情况压？

wfxmfwjwUID: 3582171

作者是根据v 的refined but legitimate observations的theory，得出的结论，也就是说v的observations是没问题的，只是结论出了问题

wfxmfwjwUID: 3582171

无敌浩克One 发表于 2015-6-5 22:17
还有这篇
Tillie Olsen’s fiction and essays have been widely and rightly acknowledged as major cont ...

I do not mean that one can adequately explain the eloquence of her work in terms of its political origins，
political origins，这里说之前的3个都是political origins

ally1213UID: 2948121

我理解得比较简单。题干的意思：关于V这个theory 作者觉得以下哪个是对的。。E我一开始看的时候略不靠谱，但是ABCD都排除了只剩那个。

无敌浩克OneUID: 3605802

wfxmfwjw 发表于 2015-6-7 13:01
I do not mean that one can adequately explain the eloquence of her work in terms of its political  ...

由原来如此，谢谢！！

无敌浩克OneUID: 3605802

ally1213 发表于 2015-6-7 18:54
我理解得比较简单。题干的意思：关于V这个theory 作者觉得以下哪个是对的。。E我一开始看的时候略不靠谱，但 ...

谢谢！！