- 最后登录
- 2011-9-12
- 在线时间
- 413 小时
- 寄托币
- 561
- 声望
- 36
- 注册时间
- 2009-11-2
- 阅读权限
- 20
- 帖子
- 1
- 精华
- 0
- 积分
- 630
- UID
- 2720580
 
- 声望
- 36
- 寄托币
- 561
- 注册时间
- 2009-11-2
- 精华
- 0
- 帖子
- 1
|
发表于 2009-12-28 02:05:59
|显示全部楼层
当当当~当~
番茄童鞋和小九童鞋的argu过程记录,觉得很有意思,发现比平时写comment话多多了=。=
首先番茄童鞋发言(Plause)
Art comes from life and beyond life, as a result, it confuses the outsiders in certain ways. How to judge the value of it and by which way can you appreciate it keep us away. Without revelent knowledge, we are following the trend, objectlessly and unconditionally. Mostly, it shares the same signal with other goods, that is, money it has fetched.
As numerous cases were given from the article, i'm more likely shocked by the doubled or tripled price of a painting at acution. According to Mason, an active buyer, inflation enables the prosperity of the art market. In addition,he determines the art as quality ones, however, i see it in an irony way. Art today, is brewed by outsiders, who are more concerned about its value of potential price rather than of art itself. No wonder Vincent Van Gogh were getting famous long after his death.
接着,小九童鞋举手发言(Silent)
Vincent Van Gogh's brother was a dealer too. He found the value of Vincent's works, and believed that Vincent would be successful even though few people enjoyed his works at that time. Without his help, Vincent could not leave so many beatiful paintings to the world.
As far as I concern, it's not a tragedy or irony that the dealers buy the art works. From anther perspective, they value the art works of different styles and boost the art market, which can advance the arts.
番茄童鞋听到,高兴地说,小九,我们来argu~
Thanks to dealers, we have an opportunity to see masters' works. However, dealer himself is a business man rather than a critic. Apple in his eye is the potential value rather than art itself. I have been long informed that Vincent Van Gogh's brother is a dealer, and he can hardly sell Vincent Van Gogh's paintings until his death. Ideas like"why after?" keep haunting me.I'm not familiar with the running system of art market, but what i see in this field is that fate of an artist is determined by merchant rather by expertise.
You may argue, Vincent Van Gogh was not lucky enough to meet the right guy. I'd rather to take my stand from the article above. As the author put it,“They are happy to pay over the odds for top-ranking pictures, but leave the rest untouched.” If dealers boost the art market, they shrink it as well. Choosen ones fetch a great amount of money, while the unpicked ones can only stand aside. Who is judging the rules? Merchant only."Mr Mason said he bought the picture forstock, with no particular collector in mind.“To them, art is only a goods to invest, a better investment under the economical crisis.
When animal bronze heads from Old Summer Palace appears in the auction hall, we are lost under mere patriotism. What kind of art they are? Being titled with the heritage of Old Summer Palace alone,enables these kind of heads valve themself millions. Ironical, they are only faucets, even not a delicate decoration comparatively to the other lost heritage. What indeed make it valuable is the merchant, because they are known it by heart, Chinese will buy it someday out of patriotism.
小九于是吭哧吭哧憋了半天,写了一个比自己的comment还要长的argu~
First of all, I agree that dealer himself is a business man rather than a critic. But you know, most dealers have the same point of view with the critics. The same example of Vincent Van Gogh, who did not enjoy his works? Neither dealers nor critics. Maybe you will remember Gauguin Paul, the guy who was cut a ear off by Vincent, his works also were not accepted. The reason was the art circle did not see the value of post-impressionism at that time, but not because the dealers were not far-sights.
Furthermore, I disagree that if dealers boost the art market, they shrink it as well. How do they shrink it? Do not buy any works at all? It’s impossible. They only could buy a style of the works instead of another one. They could change their taste but could not change the proceeding that buy art works. Because they need the works to protect them from the inflation or increase in value as the report was concerned.
Finally, what is the purpose of the artists? To express their emotion, spirit, and show a world of heart to other people of course. But at the same time, they want to be accepted, want to be enjoyed, and also want their works to be sold for earn their lives. Maybe you should say it’s a pity for art, but it’s the reality. And the dealers buy their works can encourge or help them continue their work. What is there against it and why they can not go ahead with it?
小九刚得意地想,写了这么多字啊。窃喜中发现番茄童鞋的用词和句式都比自己丰富,自己只会they do, they do not~
a little down, 但是瞬间振作,要继续努力啊,我还是有成长空间滴,我还年轻~
(画外音:没老死你~pia 飞ing) |
|