- 最后登录
- 2011-6-23
- 在线时间
- 62 小时
- 寄托币
- 584
- 声望
- 66
- 注册时间
- 2006-10-2
- 阅读权限
- 20
- 帖子
- 0
- 精华
- 1
- 积分
- 433
- UID
- 2258254
- 声望
- 66
- 寄托币
- 584
- 注册时间
- 2006-10-2
- 精华
- 1
- 帖子
- 0
|
30# movenna
1.学校应该花时间教general subject还是special subject
The impact that education has had on our history and society in general, is undeniable. It seems to become even greater as popularization of compulsory education continues to grow, providing more and more people opportunities of being educated. Thus, education plays a more and more primary but important role for every of us in our daily life. However when it comes to whether schools should take time on teaching general subjects or special subjects, the notions of people vary from one to another.
2,3句建议修改一下合成一句话,more and more出现两次,在文章开头应该尽量避免这样的现象。The notions of people看上去怪怪的,你可以说opinion, interpretation, 甚至不用加of people. 不过整个第一段没有你自己的观点,会让文章显得论点不清晰。
( g) X, I: |6 sWell, as I am concerned, both the general subjects and special subjects show the beneficial merits to people. General subject, such as fundamental mathematics, foreign language, and classical literature, is an essential and indispensable section of education. It can open one’s sight and broaden his horizons, aimed to help us knowing our world and nature better. While the importance and advantage of special subject is also apparent. People would find their jobs and develop their career by using the special skills that they have gained from the special subject, for example, biological engineering, IT, or management.
开头的well去掉,写作不是口语,尽量不要让你的文风显得太随便。虽然美国人可能会这样写,但是这是基于人家是母语的基础上。Beneficial 和merits重复,去掉一个。Horizon用的不好。Knowing应该改为understanding。While—meanwhile.
这段给人的感觉是没说完。例子是要为中心服务,你把最后一个例子放在那,什么都不说,使这段的意思非常不完整,建议你加一个总结句在后面。
So, in my opinion, it depends on the purpose of education and the age of people that schools should choose to teach general subject or special subject. For children or teenagers, general subject is more important for them as they should learn wide knowledge about our planet, out nature, out society, and our universe. On the contrary, for undergraduates and adults, it’s better to study special subject deeply in one area, and therefore they can make a suitable and sufficient preparation for the successful jobs or lives in the future.
这一段的语言问题不多。在读第一遍的时候我觉得整段立意也ok,不过第二遍读的时候我产生了一个疑问,我自己也不确定,我们可以讨论一下:题目是学校应该教general 还是special的课程,那么这个主体就应该是学校,但是在这一段里,你论证的是不同年龄的人们怎么样,主体变成了人。是不是应该更多的提及一些学校呢,比如,在讲孩子那一段,讲完了应该加上,所以,小学和中学要提供general的课,后面的部分同理。是不是这样才是紧扣题目来论证,你觉得呢?
0 ~0 `- E+ j& q5 ]: w7 p6 f; LFrom what has been discussed above, I am fully convinced that not only general subject but also special subject is good to the development of people’s career and the requirement of people’s life. Schools should make the right decision about what subjects to be taught, in accord with the real situation. No matter how the choice is, schools, a place full of information, should never fail to provide as much knowledge as people want.
No matter how---no matter what.
结尾段结合通篇来看,你的论点都不够清晰。我个人是比较倾向于在这种二选一的题目中,明明白白的选择一个观点来论证,一来可以论证的更加充分,二来可以使自己的观点很清晰。我没有尝试过选择你这样的思路,我觉得风险更大一些,呵呵,不知道坛子里有没有同学在实战时用过这样的结构写文章,不知道给分情况如何,如果有这方面的信息也请提供给我。就你这篇文章,我认为既然你选择了从两个方面来说,并且你的观点是,学校教什么课取决于实际情况,那么你一定要充分论证你的观点,多举一些例子,而不是像现在这样,仅用了一小段来谈。甚至,你整个第二段都可以省掉,而变成一个分论点,为什么学校教什么课取决于实际情况。可以想两到三个原因来,每个一段,分开来谈;比如,人们在选择不同的学校时目的不同;比如学校的资金,资源等等,总之越具体越好。写着写着突然想到,其实这样的话使你自己很被动,因为你要考虑的情况要多很多,所以我还是建议你选择一方面来谈比较好,呵呵:)可以选择那种两正一反的结构,多少也照顾到另外的方面,但是还是要突出你本来的论点。 |
-
总评分: 寄托币 + 20
声望 + 5
查看全部投币
|