经济phd陶瓷回复后求指导哈。。大谢！！

dylanduanUID: 3462199

各位大神，求陶瓷指导啊哈。。之前给某教授发了邮件，主要是谈了谈研究兴趣等，此教授不久后回复如下：
Dear XXX,

Thank you for your email. I think your CV and work is impressive, but I also think there is no need to worry about these issues at such an early stage, because you should first find out what your options are in terms of Ph.D. programmes. I know that one reason why people write to faculty is first to gauge their fit with a programme, and second to make a positive impression so as to increase chances of admission. For the first, I think it’s really quite hard to do this because faculty change institutions all the time, and also students change their research interests as they mature and learn more about a subject. For the second, in this case I have no influence on the admissions process so that is irrelevant.

Nonetheless, I think it is very nice of you to make the effort to reach out, and I think it is not a bad idea to do so in general. I wish you all the best with your applications and should you be admitted to NTU certainly we can discuss this issue if you are considering NTU as an option.

Please do send in your application to XXX through the regular channels, and I wish you the best of luck!

求问这篇回复有啥含义么？谢谢各位哈~~~

zhedaliupengUID: 3412121

经济学PhD录取是committee决定的，和教授套磁意义不大吧！

meishengtaoUID: 3410496

就是说，嗯，呵呵，不错，拿到offer一切好说，在那之前一切免谈

dylanduanUID: 3462199

meishengtao 发表于 2013-9-25 15:02
就是说，嗯，呵呵，不错，拿到offer一切好说，在那之前一切免谈

是不是坡国陶瓷作用不大啊哈？

meishengtaoUID: 3410496

dylanduan 发表于 2013-9-25 18:58
是不是坡国陶瓷作用不大啊哈？

NUS基本不用陶瓷，教授没权力（可能有部分专业例外，不清楚）；NTU一般建议陶瓷，教授权力较大（可能也有部分专业例外，不清楚）

amaibaobaoUID: 2640156

感觉至少这个老师已经表达了：我没权利 所以找我没用  你赶紧找别人吧

这个老师愿意花这么大篇幅回复并且说的这么实在 真心不错啊