本帖最后由 海王泪 于 2009-11-23 23:21 编辑
Present Your Perspective on an Issue Task (陈述你对于议题的观点) Understanding the Issue Task(明白写一篇Issue的任务、目的) The "Present Your Perspective on an Issue" task assesses your ability to think critically about a topic of general interest and to clearly express your thoughts about it in writing. Each topic, presented in quotation marks, makes a claim about an issue that test takers can discuss from various perspectives and apply to many different situations or conditions. Your task is to present a compelling case for your own position on the issue. Be sure to read the claim carefully and think about it from several points of view, considering the complexity of ideas associated with those perspectives. Then, make notes about the position you want to develop and list the main reasons and examples that you could use to support that position. 每一个话题都有其主张,应试者可以从多个角度出发、运用多种情况和条件对这个主张进行讨论,你的任务是展现一篇令人信服的文章,这篇文章是为了描述你的立场。 你要确定的是: a)仔细审题 b)从多个角度出发 c)考虑这些不同角度的观点的复杂性 d)提纲:立场、主要原因、例子 The Issue task allows considerable latitude in the way you respond to the claim. Although it is important that you address the central issue, you are free to take any approach you wish. For example, you might • agree absolutely with the claim, disagree completely, or agree with some parts and not others • question the assumptions the statement seems to be making • qualify any of its terms, especially if the way you define or apply a term is important to developing your perspective on the issue • point out why the claim is valid in some situations but not in others • evaluate points of view that contrast with your own perspective • develop your position with reasons that are supported by several relevant examples or by a single extended example Address the central issue, then: a) Position, b) Assumption/Condition, c) Definition, d) Situation, e) Contrast, f) Reasons and examples Structure: PositionßReasonsßSupported Examples (several relevant or single extended)
(Definition, Assumption, Situation)
a) Position 同意、反对、肯定一部分而否定另一部分 b) Assumption/condition 质疑假设/条件 c) Definition 定义关键词 d) Situation 分情况讨论 e) Contrast 比较观点(差异)、识别观点背后的复杂性(情况、条件) f) Reasons and examples (several relevant ones or a single extended one) 通过理由来形成你的立场,通过几个相关的例子或一个可延展的例子来支持你的理由。 The GRE readers scoring your response are not looking for a "right" answer—in fact, there is no correct position to take. Instead, the readers are evaluating the skill with which you articulate and develop an argument to support your position on the issue. 考察能力:(清楚表达和展开)论证,目的是支持己方立场 Understanding the Context for Writing: Purpose and Audience 明白写作的背景:目的和观众 The Issue task is an exercise in critical thinking and persuasive writing. The purpose of this task is to determine how well you can develop a compelling argument supporting your own perspective on an issue and to effectively communicate that argument in writing to an academic audience. Your audience consists of college and university faculty who are trained as GRE readers to apply the scoring criteria identified in the scoring guide for “Present Your Perspective on an Issue" (see page 27). Issue任务是关于批判性思维和说服性写作的练习。 任务的目的在于考察你有多擅长于构建令人信服的论证以支持你的观点以及有效表达论证。 To get a clearer idea of how GRE readers apply the Issue scoring criteria to actual responses, you should review scored sample Issue essay responses and readers' commentaries. The sample responses, particularly at the 5 and 6 score levels, will show you a variety of successful strategies for organizing, developing, and communicating a persuasive argument. The readers' commentaries discuss specific aspects of analysis and writing, such as the use of examples, development and support, organization, language fluency, and word choice. For each response, the commentary points out aspects that are particularly persuasive as well as any that detract from the overall effectiveness of the essay. 为了清楚明白阅卷人是如何实行Issue的评分标准,你应该看一看范文和阅卷人评论 范文(特别是5分和6分)将会告诉你多种(组织、展开和表达)的成功策略以构建令人信服的论证。 阅卷人评论关于分析和写作的具体方面,如例子的运用、展开和支持、结构、语言流畅性、词汇的选择。对于每一篇文章,评论都会指出有哪些方面是特别具备说服力同时也不忘提及哪些方面在整体上拖累了文章的有效性。
Organizing: Organization
Developing: The use of examples, Development and support
Communicating: Language fluency, Word choice Preparing for the Issue Task(准备Issue) Because the Issue task is meant to assess the persuasive writing skills that you have developed throughout your education, it has been designed neither to require any particular course of study nor to advantage students with a particular type of training. Many college textbooks on composition offer advice on persuasive writing that you might find useful, but even this advice might be more technical and specialized than you need for the Issue task. You will not be expected to know specific critical thinking or writing terms or strategies; instead, you should be able to use reasons, evidence, and examples to support your position on an issue. Suppose, for instance, that an Issue topic asks you to consider whether it is important for government to provide financial support for art museums. (1)If your position is that government should fund art museums, you might support your position by discussing the reasons art is important and explain that museums are public places where art is available to anyone. On the other hand,(2) if your position is that government should not support museums, you might point out that, given limited governmental funds, art museums are not as deserving of governmental funding as are other, more socially important, institutions. Or, (3)if you are in favor of government funding for art museums only under certain conditions, you might focus on the artistic criteria, cultural concerns, or political conditions that you think should determine how—or whether—art museums receive government funds. It is not your position that matters so much as the critical thinking skills you display in developing your position. ETS并不期望你知道一些具体的批判性思维、写作术语或策略; ETS希望的是看到你如何去使用理由、证据和例子来支持你的立场 An excellent way to prepare for the Issue task is to practice writing on some of the published topics. There is no "best" approach: some people prefer to start practicing without regard to the 45-minute time limit; others prefer to take a "timed test" first and practice within the time limit. No matter which approach you take when you practice the Issue task, you should review the task directions, then 不管你是否限时写,你都需要看一看Task Directions (考试界面的指引) • carefully read the claim made in the topic and make sure you understand the issue involved; if it seems unclear, discuss it with a friend or teacher • think about the issue in relation to your own ideas and experiences, to events you have read about or observed, and to people you have known; this is the knowledge base from which you will develop compelling reasons and examples in your argument that reinforce, negate, or qualify the claim in some way • decide what position on the issue you want to take and defend—remember you are free to agree or disagree completely or to agree with some parts or some applications but not others • decide what compelling evidence (reasons and examples) you can use to support your position 仔细阅读题目的主张,确定你明白复杂难懂的Issue;如果不太清楚某题, 和你的朋友或老师讨论 琢磨Issue时,想想你自己的点子和经历,想象你读过或看过的事,想想你知道的人;这些都是你自己在立论时有力的理由和例子,他们可以用来加强、否定或限制Issue中的主张。 选择你想持有和辩护的立场—记得你有自由去完全同意或反对或是部分同意部分反对 决定使用哪些令人信服证据(理由和例子)来支持你的立场 Remember that this is a task in critical thinking and persuasive writing. Therefore, you might find it helpful to explore the complexity of a claim in one of the topics by asking yourself the following questions: • What, precisely, is the central issue? • Do I agree with all or with any part of the claim? Why or why not? • Does the claim make certain assumptions? If so, are they reasonable? • Is the claim valid only under certain conditions? If so, what are they? • Do I need to explain how I interpret certain terms or concepts used in the claim? • If I take a certain position on the issue, what reasons support my position? • What examples—either real or hypothetical—could I use to illustrate those reasons and advance my point of view? Which examples are most compelling? 你可以通过自问自答的方式来探究话题主张的复杂性: 中心议题是什么? 我是否同意或只同意当中的一部分?为什么同意或为什么不同意呢? 主张是否存在某些假设?如果是,它们合理吗? 主张是否在某些条件下是有效的?如果有效,条件是什么? 我是否需要解释主张中的某些关键词或概念? 如果我选择了某个立场,有哪些理由支持我的立场? 有哪些(真实或假设的)例子是我能够用来阐明理由或发展观点的?哪些例子是最有说服力的? Once you have decided on a position to defend, consider the perspective of others who might not agree with your position. Ask yourself: • What reasons might someone use to refute or undermine my position? • How should I acknowledge or defend against those views in my essay? 一旦你选定了某个立场为自己辩护,考虑有可能存在的反方观点,自己问自己: 有哪些理由是其他人用来驳倒或暗中减弱我的立场? 我应该如何承认或辩解哪些反方观点? To plan your response, you might want to summarize your position and make brief notes about how you will support the position you're going to take. When you've done this, look over your notes and decide how you will organize your response. Then write a response developing your position on the issue. Even if you don't write a full response, you should find it helpful to practice with a few of the Issue topics and to sketch out your possible responses. After you have practiced with some of the topics, try writing responses to some of the topics within the 45-minute time limit so that you have a good idea of how to use your time in the actual test. 你可以总结你的立场以及做简要的笔记来记录你是如何支持你的立场,紧接着审视这些笔记再决定如何组织你的文章,然后再开始动笔写文章。 即使你不打算写完整的一篇文章,你会发现练习一些Issue的题目并列提纲是大有裨益的。在你练习了一些题目后,试试限时模考,这样有助于你明白在实际考试中如何掌握时间。 It would probably be helpful to get some feedback on your response from an instructor who teaches critical thinking or writing or to trade papers on the same topic with other students and discuss one another's responses in relation to the scoring guide. Try to determine how each paper meets or misses the criteria for each score point in the guide. Comparing your own response to the scoring guide will help you see how and where you might need to improve. 通过得到一些教批判性思维或写作的老师对你文章的反馈,或是和其他撰写同样话题的学生互改和根据评分细则来对文章进行讨论。尝试判断每一篇文章是如何符合或未达到评分标准,注意细则中的每一点都要有所涉及。比较你的文章和评分细则有助于你认识到如何以及哪里还需要提高。
|