- 最后登录
- 2012-5-27
- 在线时间
- 565 小时
- 寄托币
- 559
- 声望
- 15
- 注册时间
- 2010-1-27
- 阅读权限
- 25
- 帖子
- 4
- 精华
- 0
- 积分
- 615
- UID
- 2755904

- 声望
- 15
- 寄托币
- 559
- 注册时间
- 2010-1-27
- 精华
- 0
- 帖子
- 4
|
TOPIC: ISSUE69 - "Government should place few, if any, restrictions on scientific research and development"
WORDS: 670
TIME: 00:59:34
DATE: 2010-5-25 20:29:42
Should restrictions be place on scientific research and development? I think the answer is positive. Even though few restrictions on researches and developments have merits, both financial and legal restrictions should be placed by government as the development will cause side effects and ethical problems and lots of social resources has plowed into these scientific researches and developments. And therefore the government should play a circumscribed role when it comes to scientific research and development, because it is the government's responsibility to ensure that the social resources are used effectively and efficiently.
When we only take the pace of the research and development into consideration, little restrictions on them, especially in the field like medical or biology, sometimes have merit for the researchers will doing their research without the restrain of the social ethics, which usually hinder the pace of scientific research and development. For instance, as there are laws which protect the right of wild animals and stop man from inordinately using them in medical experiments, medical research which entails lots of wild animals to continue the experiments if little legal restraint are place on it. Thus, if we only take into accounts the pace of the research or development, the suggestion that placing little restrains on scientific research and development does have merit.
However, it is sectarian of us to merely taking the pace into consideration while side effect caused by the little restrain on research and development are also indispensable when it comes to the scientific research and development, in which case little restrains on them are not enough. Since some scientific research and development will lead to ethical problems or side effect on the environment, appropriate amount of restriction on them are necessary. For instance, when the technology of clone, which render it possible for human to clone themselves, showed up, the development of this technology is greatly circumscribed because it will arise ethical problems of the dignity of life. If no restriction was placed upon this scientific development, the cloning of human will surely lead to disorder in society both mentally and physically, as no decisive conclusion has been made upon the right of human cloned. Similarly, the little restriction of scientific research and development will possibly lead to side effect on the environment, as the first industrial revolution, which is one of the most influential scientific developments in human history, led to severe contamination of the environment. Thus, when we speculate on the side effects and the ethical problems which the scientific research and development will cause, there is no denying of the effectiveness of adequate amount of restriction on them.
Moreover, since the scientific research and development are funded by the whole society which provides social resources, such as money or welfare, it is the public's right to authorized the government to cast restrictions on these researches and developments in order to ensure the efficient and effective use of the social resources. Social resources are limited, which makes it necessary to plow the resource where it can be most helpful toward benefiting the public. For that matter, scientific research is not the only thing the government should invest social resources into; other parts of the society, such as education system, legal system, also lack social resources. Therefore, the government has to ensure the efficient and effective use of social resources plowed into scientific development. Otherwise, these resources can be effectively used in other areas. If this is the case, the government should play a circumscribed role when it comes to scientific research and development and little restrictions are not enough.
In sum, even though the suggestion that place few, if any, restrictions on scientific research and development has merit when merely reflecting on the pace of the research, adequate amount of legal and financial restrains on them are necessary since the government not only has to ponder over the side effect and ethical problems scientific researches brings but also has to affirm the efficient as well as the effective use of social resources in scientific research and development.
|
|