大家罗列、讨论一下argument里逻辑特别混乱，特别难分析的题目吧

tangjihedeUID: 2107695

59黑子那个我在这个帖子里列过一个提纲了。
153：
1。fallacy of concurrence犯罪率和电视没有必然关系
2。national studies show的是within their home environment
3. the validity of Observer's survey is open to doubt.
4. even granted the survey is reliable and TV programs should be responsible for the increasing crime rate, it does not necessarily follow that TV programmers should reduce the amount of violence shown during prime time, for it is highly possible that not so many children watch these program during that time; maybe they should reduce violent programs of other periods.

tangjihedeUID: 2107695

197.
1. fails to prove that objectives are really indispensable.
2. significance of questionnaires. parents'and employers opinions might also be counted,
3.an official statment will necessarily result in improved programs?
4.this activity might lead to undesirable influence. disturb teachers and studetns....

tangjihedeUID: 2107695

237
1.fails to prove that those financials inducements of D are really successful. there might be other reasons accouting for the relocation of two companies.
2.even granted...the arguer still fails to show that D solves the unemployment problem well. 300 people employed by those two comanies might come from other cities. Even they are native employees, perhaps this number could be neglectable compared with huge number of unemployment.
3.fallacy of false analogy.
4"private company"?

tangjihedeUID: 2107695

谁能给个清楚的分析或提纲？

[ Last edited by tangjihede on 2005-8-6 at 15:24 ]

yogurt4UID: 198389

197
楼上的分析的很8错,我也来补充下
1,题目:never once in our 150-year history as a universityhave we clarified our objectives
but every department may have its definite goal.
2 Why  we should clear our objectives?
To adapt to the new challenges facing......
But what are the challenges? Maybe this university is as good as MIT, so its problem may be too many students applying it every year.In short, the word "challenge" is  vague , emotional, and meaningless.

zmmaryUID: 2105117

借用之后，给顶一下，说不准会对谁有用呢。呵呵。：）

嘶喊的牧歌UID: 197463

好贴。必须来学习了。

鬼谷子UID: 159645

顶，最近问argument的朋友不少，来参考一下

ouymUID: 2109118

好贴，明天我来细细地看一下！

AugustsonUID: 166116

我考试遇到的是grizzle bear and black bear的题，当时都绿了
读题就读了5分钟，而且题目竟然说的是probably~~~~~
Crumble~~~~~~~~

tz0412UID: 180794

177,178,大家都找到两个错误了？

kolu_renUID: 158196

大家好热闹噢！我也要仔细研究一下，明天再上来参加大家的讨论。 我把大家提出来的题目都列了一下，方便查阅！;)

tz0412UID: 180794

Originally posted by kolu_ren at 2005-8-10 16:10
大家好热闹噢！我也要仔细研究一下，明天再上来参加大家的讨论。 我把大家提出来的题目都列了一下，方便查阅！;)

good job，多谢拉，确实这样方便了许多。

ssssssluluUID: 2116615

好铁，顶顶！
这几天刚开工阿狗，来好好研究一下
还有14天了（说半个月有点点安慰感），全力以赴！

AlexandraUID: 185174

不过 你只列了 讨论到的题目
以后有时间 把 大家的提纲 也 弄进去吧